tree defects when planting trees

Quality Nursery Stock- You Can Grow That, Nov.

In Fall, Gardening, Tree Planting, You Can Grow That by Forest Keeper11 Comments

The temperatures are dropping in most climate zones  and our outdoor growing season is coming to an end ( sort of).  But did you know that November is  a great time to plant new trees in your landscape.  There are many factors from a plant health perspective that make November a good planting time. Perhaps you have already discovered another advantage to a late fall planting. Reduced cost!  Many garden centers and nurseries will offer tree stock at cheaper prices in  order to sell down their overstock for the season. I have purchased many quality trees at this time of the year at great deals and have been pleased at how well they have done since their planting.

You do need to choose your plant stock wisely however, as it is often the case that you are choosing from the “left-overs” from the season gone by. If you know what you are looking for it will not be too difficult to decide which trees are going to grace  your yard with years of beauty and shade and which trees are going to need replacement in just a few short years.

First lets look at the roots

Here are some things to look out for When selecting your tree:

Circling roots

tree defects when planting trees

Look out for circling roots in the root ball. This will occur more often in container grown stock but it can happen in some balled and burlaped trees.

things to watch out for- planting healthy trees

Circling roots will more often than not develop into large girdling roots. This will put a great deal of stress on your tree. In time, your tree will become weak, stressed, and prone to disease. Ultimately your tree will die prematurely from this problem.

Most often you can see this defect on the top of the root ball. You may have to pull the tree out of the containers to see this problem on some trees. Trees with roots that circle around the bottom and sides of a container are called “pot bound” or “root bound” and have likely been in a  container a size too small for a while. Trees with this problem will not prosper and often die from stress related diseases at an early age.

Girdling roots cause ttrouble for new tree plantings

Circling roots can start off seemingly small, and inconsequential.

If ignored however, those girdling roots become a leading cause of mortality for new plantings. Look at this tangled mess of self choking roots.

Kinked roots

Kinked roots, much like circling roots, are often caused from trees growing in too small of containers for too long .These deflecting roots will keep your tree from growing in to the full stature that a tree on your property should have.

tree root defects- planting healthy trees

Tree roots that are kinked or deflected at extreme and awkward angles can cause problems for a tree. Water and sugars have a difficult time passing this severe turn in the root. Kinked roots can also cause a tree to be unstable and loose in the soil.

This kinked root will ultimately cause problems for this tree as it grows.


When young, smaller kinked roots can be pruned out with some degree of success but it is better to avoid these problems all together if you have other plant stock available to you.


Checking the root flare

Another thing that you will want to look for in the root system of your tree is the root flare. That’s the area of trunk that transitions into roots just at ground level. The root flare should be just above ground.

proper tree planting depth is determined by the root flare.

The root flare of a tree should be located just above the soil level.If possible, look for trees in the nursery that are already, in the ball or container, at the proper depth.

Often times, trees come from the nursery, already buried in the ball. If this tree has been in this state for too long, damage will have been inflicted on the bark tissue and stress related diseases and trunk rot can easily occur.










On more common root problem that nursery stock can often develop is a loose root ball. If the tree trunk moves back and forth in the root ball easily then this tree will have trouble standing up without some sort of guy system and it will have trouble putting out any new root growth.

Now let’s look at the stem and limbs

Carefully look at the stem and main branches of the tree. Do you see any damage from insects or diseases? Is there any mechanical damage and wounds on the stem from rough handling ?

Torn bark and frost cracks on the stem will serve as entry points for decay to enter the tree in the future. Check for swollen areas  and any signs of  cankers, scale, and borer damage on the trunk.

planting healthy trees- looking for stem problems

Look care fully at the stem and limbs of trees before purchasing. This tree has been chewed on quite a bit by a rabbit. This will lead to a decline in the trees long term health.

Look out for any damage to the stem such as this canker which has killed the cambium layer of this tree. Damage like this could be caused by a disease or just by rough handling.

Codominant stems

Codominant stems are two or more trunks on a tree that are both taking on the role as the main leader for upward growth in the tree, as opposed to one single trunk with many lateral branches.

The ideal structure for a tree is one central stem with evenly spaced lateral growth growing from that stem. Trees with co-dominant stems are lesser in quality because of their inherent weakness. Trees with two or more stems, clustered together are prone to splitting apart as they grow bigger and experience high wind or snow fall.


This trait is considered a defect because often the angle between these two stems is such that the attachment is a weak point in the tree. Trees with co-dominant stems are more likely to fail in storm events.

Improper pruning cuts

Sometimes vendors sell trees with improper pruning cuts such as stubs or flush cuts. Stubs are branches that are pruned in the middle of the branch, rather than outside of the branch collar of a lateral branch or trunk where proper cuts should be made. Proper cuts are made just outside of a branch collar because this part of a tree is equipped to actively seal over the wound and prevent decay. This function is not as active in the middle of a branch, and stubs are more susceptible to decay and sprouting. Flush cuts occur when a pruning cut is made right at the trunk, which removes the branch collar. This is also an improper cut which makes the tree more susceptible to decay. Look for minimal stubs or flush cuts on the tree you purchase. If a few stubs are present, they can be pruned back to a branch collar.

Stub cut such as this are not only unattractive but unhealthy for the tree. Watch out for trees that have too many stubbed branches and improper cuts as they will have abnormal growth patterns.

On the other hand, a tree with many flush cuts is not desirable either. These types of cuts make it difficult for the tree to close over the wound with new callous growth  and create an opening for decay to set into the stem.

Learn how to identify and make proper pruning cuts.

correct and incorrect pruning cuts

So again, November is a great time to plant a new tree in your landscape. It is possible to find quality trees at this time and  with a little bit of attention to the condition of the tree your tree you can select a tree that will last for many years to come and will add beauty and value to your property.

Quality trees from healthy nursery stock: You can grow that!






  1. Great post! Thanks for the tips. It are definitely things I would not have thought about when buying a tree.
    Trees are expensive to buy, we have one large garden centre in the area and they charge whatever they want, I would have hated to spend a lot of money for a tree in order to see it die.

    1. Author

      Hi Laila. Yes it is true. If we are going to make the investment on new trees we want to make sure that they were grown right and that we plant then right. this way our investment will last for generations and not just a few years.

  2. Great post. Thank you and I shared it on Facebook. Long time no see! Every year at the Rotary show we connect but then you never call_both very busy. I like your web site and blogs_great job.

    1. Author

      Thanks Elaine. I’m glad to hear that you are having a busy season as well!

  3. Fantastic post that really illustrates what to look for when buying and planting a tree. I especially love the photo of the xtra layers of soil cut away from the trunk of that tree before you planted it.

  4. Author

    Buried root flares is a very common problem that is easily remedied. I am amazed at how often I see trees planted too deep because of this.

  5. Thank you for such an informative post! Where I live (Tampa, Fla.), young trees grow so quickly with our heavy summer rains, and you really have to prune or risk them becoming top-heavy and blowing over or (with big trees) dropping one of those co-dominant trunks on your house.
    Though I’ve been gardening for years, I still have trouble recognizing potbound roots, unless it’s a really serious case. Don’t all potted plants (including trees) have roots growing in a generally circular fashion?

  6. Author

    Very often yes, most container plants do have circling roots to some degree. But if a tree has been re-potted as often as it should be as it grows, this will not be a problem. Circular roots are quite simply the result of being in a small pot for too long. If left for extended periods, these roots can become very pronounced.
    The above roots are pretty nice looking as opposed to these below,

    If your plant has relatively young circling roots or not very many, these can be either pruned off or you can break up their continuity by “roughing them up” with a tool before planting.

  7. How do you help a tree when the truck exposes the dead cambium layer? It’s still alive but covered in ants. We’re killing the ants but the bark is coming off. What can we do?

Leave a Comment